I have
just finished reading a book called “Butter” by Japanese writer Asako Yuzuki.
The central
character is a female Japanese journalist, Rika, who is attempting to interview
a woman, Manako, who is currently awaiting a retrial for the murder of several
men. She needs to find an “in” with this
woman where all other journalists have failed. In doing
so, she ends up discovering so much more about herself.
Manako
is a cook who is accused of murdering several of her previous boyfriends. The authorities allege that she seduced these men
with her food to lure them into being her boyfriend, before killing them in
various different manners.
One of
the themes running through this book is that the lady is fat and as such, she
is far from the accepted norm to be able to get a boyfriend in Japanese
society. What seems to fascinate the Japanese
press and the public in this book is not so much the why/if she killed them, but
how she got them to be with her in the first place.
The
crimes committed in this book are not the main focus. Neither is whether Manako is guilty, or
not. Indeed, they are a side note to it.
Food
is the language of this book. The writer
talks about simple ingredients, such as butter, as being filled with meaning.
Meals are not just to fill you up or for fuel; they are expressions of the way
that you enjoy food, indulge in it, give yourself permission to have it. The way that it makes you feel. The control, the intimacy, and the rebellion of simply
eating.
"When I'm eating good butter, I feel somehow as though I were falling"
As Rika delves further deeper into her interviews with Manako, her relationship with
food changes and soon after, the way that she understands herself. When she starts to think about, truly take the time to enjoy the food and the start to cook herself, she feels at first liberated and then strangely, like every mouthful is an act of confrontation.
Yes, I am allowing myself to eat this thing. And?
It is
a taking back of power that she did not realise she had lost.
It did make me think about the relationship we have with food and drink. Simple pleasures, or big indulgences. Taking the time to enjoy them. Be in the moment. Whether it is a icy cold glass of water that tastes like it has come from a mountain pass, or a piece of chocolate so divine that you do not want it to end. Yet, instead of letting it sit on our tongue and luxuriating in it, we swallow and then feel guilty for eating it. We do not pause to truly enjoy enough.
Butter focuses sharply on the societal expectations placed on women. Beauty, appearance,
ambition, motherhood, each one is scrutinized and judged. Manako is not the norm in Japanese
society. She enjoys herself, enjoys food,
enjoys sex and pleasure and makes no apologies for it. She does not conform and finds the idea
repulsive. This makes her fascinating,
not just to Rika, but to Japanese society. Learning more about Manako forces Rika to look
at her own life and how those same expectations have shaped her, unseen and
unknowing.
What I found interesting about the book was the accurate description of how
much we unconsciously change ourselves to fit with the “norm”. The accepted.
We are given goals based on societal expectations. Goals that may not align with who we are and
what we want.
The book
looks at the female journalists on Rika’s newspaper who go on to have families. Society expects them to juggle a career and be
the perfect mothers. They are judged heavily
for both. One who was blamed for the
death of her son, because he went out to buy a meal at the shop instead of her
being there to serve him. You can have
it all, but you will be condemned if you do not do both perfectly.
Then there
was the male journalist who gave up his love of a band, because his favourite
singer gained weight and therefore became unacceptable in society’s
eyes. It was no longer cool or
acceptable to like her. So he hid it despite his love for the band.
The
idea that unless you confirm to societal expectations, you are a failure. When Rika gained weight herself as a result
of her cooking experiments it was shocking to those around her. Because she had fallen out of her box and
they no longer knew where to put her.
By the end of the book, Rika has managed to throw off the restraints of society and for the first time, in years, decades even, she is living for herself. Rebellion is attractive. Instead of her world becoming smaller, she bring more people into it, whilst throwing off the chains of expectation. It is a beautiful thing,
There are many other things in this book that I have not talked about there, otherwise there would be no point in you reading it. The story of Manako. The story of Rika's best friend.
I recommend a read.